Saturday, October 25, 2014

Do Good There or Do Good Here


A columnist for The New York Times by the name of Nicholas Kristof uses his refined journalistic sensitivities to plead the case of the poor and downtrodden in third world countries. He’s written a book in which he urges readers to donate money and/or time to help improve the lives of these people. He often works on your sense of shame to be more proactive to his pet causes.

Certainly his heart is in the right place and there is endless misery in the world that must be addressed, but Mr. Kristof and spouse seem to home in the most hopeless and most desperate. As a reader, I sympathize for the plight of the less fortunate, but where does one begin?

For the most part, the greatest misery is found in the regions of the world with the most dysfunctional leadership, which leads me to conclude that without addressing that underlying situation, our charity will be wasted or otherwise usurped by the power structure.

Mr. Kristof is an intrepid traveler and visits and meets with the most afflicted populations in the world, so naturally he is greatly moved and inspired to call the first world’s attention to the most horrific situations. But again, with the need so great, how can our pittance of support make much of a difference?

I hate to say it, but charity should begin at home. It begins by providing education and other opportunities to the next generation, your kids for instance, before you can adjust your sights outward to volunteer time and money for the community. I believe in local first. Help bootstrap the less fortunate in your town or in less affluent areas where your contribution can make the most impact.

Yes, I’d love to provide a roof and an education to the masses of unspeakably poor and abused in the Sudan and Congo, but my humble efforts are little more than spitting into the ocean. When the system is so broken, how can we know that our dollars are well spent—or spent as well as they could be if we take a more local approach? 

No comments:

Post a Comment